Barmah-Millewa Forest
including
Barmah State Park,
Gulpa Island and Moira Forest
The VEAC
draft proposals paper dated July 2007 recommends that virtually all
of Barmah Forest (Victoria) become a National Park. If the recommendation
is accepted by parliament, camping will continue to be allowed and vehicles
will be able to use formed roads (except during flood times). However,
solid wood fires, dogs, shooting, grazing and lumbering will not be
permitted. The following will be upgraded if and when the final recommendations
are passed into law. Copies of the draft proposals can be obtained from
VEAC. Submissions to VEAC close
21st September 2007. Please read the Discussion Paper and Draft Proposals
book thoroughly before making a submission or attending a consultation
session. The following information may be of interest.
One argument
being used against the proposal is that there are more trees in the
forest than before European settlement. This is correct. But it is not
a good thing. The average tree today is younger and smaller. In places,
there are thickets of saplings where Moira Grass Plains existed pre
river 'regulation'. Refer to the section on Moira Grass
Plains below.
Some are
critical of the fact that VEAC has recommended an end to commercial
cattle grazing. VEAC has left open the possibility of cattle being used
for environmental purposes, as is the case on the grasslands at Terrick
Terrick National Park. A section below examines the impact of cattle
in the forest. On the whole, cattle grazing probably does more damage
than good and may increase rather than reduce the fire risk!
Location
Bama State
Forest (NSW)
Barmah
Forest
Bushwalking
Cattle
Forestry
Geology
Gulpa Island
Indigenous
occupation
Living
Murray initiative
Management
Millewa
forest
Moira
Flora Reserve
Moira
Forest
Moira
Grass Plains
News
Other
forest areas
Potential
Threats
Located north-east of Echuca-Moama,
the Barmah-Millewa 'Forest' straddles the Victoria-NSW border and covers
about 66,600 hectares. Barmah-Millewa forest resembles a triangle in
shape with its base running roughly north-south. The 'Forest' includes
several lakes, wetlands, Moira Grass plains and sand hills. In places,
on higher ground, Black Box is the dominant tree. But Red Gum is the
dominant tree around wetlands and along the rivers. Callitris Pine is
the dominant tree on sandhills. aeolian sandhills or lunettes mark the
edge of a once larger Moira Lake. The forest is called Barmah Forest
in Victoria (28,500ha; light grey on map below ~ parts of which form
a State Park) and Millewa State Forest, Gulpa Island State Forest or
Moira State Forest in NSW (38,100ha; darker grey on map below).

Barmah-Millewa
Forest

The Living Murray initiative lists this forest
as one of six icon sites in the Murray-Darling Basin to be protected
for their ecological significance. One icon site (Os significant environmental
asset) is Barmah-Millewa Forest.
The other Living Murray icon
sites are
* Gunbower-Koondrook-Perricoota
Forest
* Hattah Lakes
* Chowilla Floodplain, Lindsay and Wallpolla Island
* The Coorong, lower lakes and river mouth, and
* the river channel itself.
Barmah-Millewa is a wetland
of International Importance under the Ramsar Convention and consideration
is being given to nominating it as an Important Bird Area (IBA) because
of its importance to the endangered Superb Parrot. It is an important
breeding ground for a number of birds, including Yellow-billed Spoonbill,
Nankeen Night Heron, Royal Spoonbill, Intermediate Egret, Great Egret
and Australian White Ibis.
The Barmah-Millewa
Forest provides habitat for numerous threatened plant and animal species,
including birds, fish and reptiles, and supports colonies of breeding
waterbirds during appropriate seasonal conditions.
The Living
Murray initiative aims to enhance forest fish and wildlife values, ensure
successful breeding of thousands of colonial waterbirds in at least
three years in ten, promote healthy vegetation in at least 55% of the
area of the forest (including virtually all of the Giant Rush, Moira
Grass, River Red Gum forest, and some River Red Gum woodland).
Because of
irrigation, natural river flow patterns differ from those which existed
pre-European settlement. The river now flows at near bankful through
The Narrows (see below) throughout summer, whilst winter-spring floods
are usually neither as deep nor as prolonged.
In attempt
to restore a natural flooding and drying regime to the forest, a number
of environmental works and measures have been completed or are planned.
There are in excess of 50 water management structures, including regulators,
pipes, culverts and earthen banks. To enable native fish to move up
and down river, fish ladders have been, or are being, installed at obstacles
such as weirs. Some of the fish ladders have traps aimed at reducing
the number of the introduced European Carp, a fish which increases river
turbidity and competes with native fish.

Regulators
such as this one at the Top End help keep water out of wetlands over
autumn and summer when river levels are artificially high, but can
be opened to allow wetlands to be flooded in late spring. (K Stockwell)
In his Australia
Day 2007 address to the National Press Club, the then Prime Minister,
Hon John Howard, announced 'engineering works for the 'Barmah Choke'.
It is important that 'The Choke' (The Narrows), a landform of considerable
significance, itself not be interfered with. The very existence of the
Barmah-Millewa wetlands depend upon channel capacity being exceeded
during late winter and spring. The wetlands should then be allowed to
dry out over late summer and autumn. A by-pass channel could be good
news for the forest if it is only used in summer and autumn. On the
other hand, if a by-pass is used all year, including late winter and
spring and early summer, causing a reduction in the depth and duration
of flooding, it could spell doom for the wetlands. The Victorian Government
has established a group to assess the proposal and the leader believes
that the project will not go ahead if the environment will be worse
off as a result. Some NSW irrigators between Tocumwal and Barmah are
particularly concerned.
Another proposal
which may result in further degradation of the wetlands is for dams
along the King and Ovens rivers. At present, flood water from these
unregulated rivers sometimes enters the Barmah-Millewa wetlands. Environmental
water is sometimes released to supplement the depth and/or duration
of flooding. Damming these rivers will not create one drop of additional
water, but it may mean a reduction of flooding in Barmah-Millewa, and
that is a bad thing.

A
view of Barmah Lake from The Narrows (K Stockwell)
Hundreds of years ago the Murray flowed north of
Echuca, along the course of what is today called Green Gully. It was
the Goulburn River that flowed through what is now Echuca. Tectonic
activity caused the land to the west of the present Barmah-Millewa Forest
to be uplifted by between 8 and 12 metres along a north-south fault
line, sloping back down to the west (the Cadell Tilt Block). The Cadell
Fault Line runs between Deniliquin and Moama. The same fault may continue
south from Echuca to, say, Runnymeade (Lake Cooper and Green Lake lay
immediately east of this fault). The westward course of the Murray was
blocked and a huge lake formed as a result. Earth movements along this
fault are still occurring. The uplift was thought to have occurred about
16,000 years ago, give or take a few thousand years.
Over
the years, the Murray tried to escape from this lake. Gulpa Creek is
an early attempt. Eventually the waters flowed around the northern edge
of the tilt block as The Edward (alongside which Deniliquin is now built)
and south as The Narrows. The Edward rejoined the old course of the
Murray near Barham. The Goulburn may have also blocked for a time. Eventually,
the Murray also found an escape to the south (The Narrows) and flowed
into the Goulburn. The Narrows is a perched river with natural silt
jetties separating it from the remnants of a once larger large, Moira
Lake and Barmah Lake. Most rivers flow in a valley but The narrows is
actually higher than the land either side, its natural levees preventing
the river from spreading out over a vast area. In flood times , The
narrows (Barmah Choke) cannot carry as much water as other parts of
the river system, so the surrounding flat land is flooded. The fault
also created numerous braided channels which distribute flood waters
throughout the forest.
Frequent flooding enabled a red gum
forest to be created, with Banksia and native Pine dominating aeolian
sand ridges which mark the retreating edge of prior lakes. Local rainfall
alone cannot support the forest.

Natural
levee, The Narrows (K Stockwell)
The Moira and Barmah Lakes are separate
only because of natural levees formed as the Murray passed through the
lake, and they are but a remnant of their former size. Hut Lake, the
Reed Beds, the Gluepot, Duffys Lagoon and Duck Lagoon are just some
of the other fragments of a once huge lake.
Today, extensive red gum forests
grow along the Murray River between Cobram, Deniliquin and Echuca-Moama.
The forest is usually referred to as the Barmah Swamp and most visitors
keep to the Victorian side. Barmah Forest, much of which is a State
Park, lies between Cobram and Barmah on the Victorian side of the Murray
River. But the term red gum forest is misleading. There are areas of
sandhills (dominated by Callitris pine), grassland (Moira Grass
plains), grassy box forest (on slightly higher areas) and both 'permanent'
and ephemeral wetlands.
Water regulation (using dams and
regulators) and extraction (e.g. for irrigation) have changed river
flow patterns, with much higher summer flows. Some wetlands had, at
least until recently, been permanently inundated, resulting in environmental
degradation. Rehabilitation schemes have been attempted (e.g. of the
Moira Lake wetlands and Reed Beds) and the Barmah-Millewa Forum was
set up to co-ordinate management of the forest. It has now been replaced
by site managers (one from each State) and a number of committees (see
below).
An area of around 1,500ha, which
includes Moira Lake and the surrounding Moira Grass plains, has been
declared a flora reserve from which cattle and forestry have been excluded.
Where appropriate, a fence has been constructed around much of the reserve
(the Moira Channel and Murray river serve as unfenced boundaries). Timber
extraction in the area has ceased and an extensive restoration programme
is well under way. A rehabilitation plan for the wetland has been developed
by the NSW Murray Wetlands Working Group, NSW State Forests and the
Department of Land and Water Conservation. Summer flows can now be excluded
from the wetland, simulating natural conditions. Access is via Cobb
Highway north of the Shepparton turnoff and immediately north of Moira
Channel (because of a locked gate, a long walk is involved) or by walking
from the southern end of Narrows Road

A
rock wall built to prevent river water from entering Moira Lake (K Stockwell)
Stage 3 of the Moira Lake Restoration
Scheme is planned. At considerable cost, the Moira Channel may be 'relocated'
so that it takes off downstream of, and skirts to the south of, Moira
Lake. The part of Moira Lake which the channel presently crosses is
expected to be rehabilitated.
Whilst the
forest and its wetlands attract lots of tourists and brings lots of
money into the region, there's another benefit: the Barmah-Millewa wetlands
are habitat for large numbers of ibis which each day travel to surrounding
farms, preying on insect pests that feed on crops and pastures. At night,
large numbers of bats leave the forest in search of insects, supplementing
the work of the ibis. This natural pest control service has been valued
at over $650,000 per annum.
A large volume
of environmental water was released to the forest over the spring and
summer of 2005-06, triggering a major bird and fish breeding event.
Three species of Egret (Great, Intermediate and Little) all bred successfully.
Other birds also bred successfully, including Nankeen Night Heron, White
Ibis and Straw-necked Ibis.
Since then,
prolonged drought conditions have prevailed and even some 'permanent'
wetlands have dried up. Giant Rush (Juncus ingens) has taken
over much of the wetlands ~ growing one and an half metres tall in just
six months ~ whilst red gum saplings have taken over other areas.
Barmah
Forest
The most-visited part
of the forest is that section of Barmah Forest which can be accessed
via the Sandridge Road from Barmah Town. The Barmah Lake is popular
with day visitors and campers alike. A small tourist boat, MV Kingfisher,
operates from the lake, offering cruises of about two hours in duration.
There is an information centre alongside Sandridge Road, north of the
turnoff to Barmah Lake but it is currently closed owing to termite damage.
Sandridge Road meets a river road.
If the roads are open and dry, motorists can drive
alongside the Murray for many kilometres. The forest can also be accessed
from tracks off both the Murray Valley Highway and Picola North Road.
Compared to
the NSW side, there are relatively few fenced exclusion plots in Victoria.
The best one, perhaps, is located near the intersection of Dargan track
and Bourke Street. The exclusion plot protects a variety of trees and
shrubs, including Buloke. However, some shrubs and trees found in places
on the NSW side appear to be absent from the Victorian side, e.g. Banksia
marginata.
There is an
interesting half-day forest drive on the Victorian side of the Murray
River from Barmah Town (VicRoads Map 31 H2) along Sand Ridge Road to
"The Gulf" and on to Morgans Beach. Because of the length
of the drive, it is best to return to Barmah via the sealed Picola-Barmah
Road.
On the NSW side of the river, the
signposted Moira Forest Drive leaves the Cobb Highway south of Mathoura
and follows Poverty Point, Narrows and Swifts Creek roads. There is
another forest drive off the Tocumwal (also called Millewa) (also called
Aratula) Road.
The drive from Mathoura along Picnic
Point Road to the Murray River is also a delightful drive although the
road has been straightened and widened and is now bitumen for most of
its length. Grey-crowned Babblers and Blue-faced Honeyeaters are often
sighted along the side road to Tarragon Lodge.
Apart from red gum forest and sandhills,
there are extensive areas of Box Forest, much of which is coppice growth
from previously-logged trees. Grey Box dominates on non-sandy areas
which do not flood very often. Black Box dominates on clay areas which
occasionally flood for short periods. Native Pine (Callitris) is the
dominant tree on sandhills. There are areas of Moira Grass Plains and
perennial wetlands. The article by Pat Corry below helps us realise
that the forest is not merely a Red Gum monoculture.
It is this forest that VEAC has recommended
become a national park. At present, parts are State Park.
Gulpa
Island
Gulpa
Island lies between the Edward River and Gulpa Creek. There is a sealed
road, Picnic Point Road, across the south end of Gulpa Island from the
Cobb Highway at Mathoura to Millewa Forest Road, the Tocumwal turnoff.
A
walking track alongside Gulpa Creek can be accessed at the edge of Mathoura,
from the first bridge over Gulpa Creek, opposite a small caravan park
and kiosk. The track features a number of bridges over Gulpa Creek.
The northern end of the walking track, near Polly's Bridge is highly
regarded by bird observers. Red-browed finches and water birds are usually
observed along this track.

Red-browed
Finch (D Ong)
Immediately
after the Picnic Point Road crosses Gulpa Creek on to Gulpa Island,
there is a vehicular track alongside the creek. The track heads north
for many kilometres before leading back to the Cobb Highway half way
between Mathoura and Deniliquin.
It is interesting
to note how Reeds are common on the town side of the creek and not as
common on the forest side where grazing has occurred.
Near
the northern end of Gulpa Creek Road, just before Gulpa Creek Road crosses
Gulpa Creek, there is a road to the right, Junction Track. A short distance
along Junction Track is the intersection with Langmans Road. Langmans
Road skirts a sandhill, a large section of which is fenced. The fenced
exclosure protects remnant sandhill vegetation, including Murray Pine,
Golden Wattle, native grasses, everlastings, Hop Bush, Calytrix and
Exocarpus. The area is popular with bird observers as Gilberts Whistler
is sometimes observed here.
Rather
than following Gulpa Creek Road all the way north, Taylor's Bridge Road
can be followed across the island and it eventually leads to Millewa
Forest Road at the Edward River Bridge. There are a number of scenic
alternatives to Millewa Forest Road, one of which is Sages Track. Emus
are often sighted along Sages Track, as are some endangered birds such
as Diamond Firetail. Southern Whiteface is often observed on or near
fallen branches along Sages Track.

Emus
along Sages Track (D Ong)
A
short distance before the bitumen ends, there is the two-storied Reed
Beds bird hide which affords splendid views over the Reed Beds,
a wetland remnant of a once huge Moira Lake. When the swamp contains
water, large numbers of water birds can be observed feeding and nesting.
The wetland has been dry for the past few years.

Bird
Hide, The Reed Beds Mathoura
The Reed Beds have been protected
by a 2,000ha exclosure in which forestry and grazing have been prohibited.
An expensive restoration programme has been undertaken and there has
been a marked improvement in the vegetation and bird life. The Reed
Beds were flooded in 2004. The modern bird viewing structure off Picnic
Point Road replaces a hide built in 1986. Unlike the old hide, there
is all-weather access to the new structure by sealed road. The walkway
has been built above the 1 in 100 year flood level. Birds which can
be viewed from the new structure from time to time include Great-crested
Grebe, Australasian Grebe, Clamorous Reed Warbler, Sacred Kingfisher,
Coot, Pelican, Little Pied Cormorant, Little Black Cormorant, Royal
Spoonbill, Yellow-billed Spoonbill, Little Grassbird, Purple Swamp Hen,
Swamp Harrier and White-bellied Sea-eagle. Access the hide via the Mathoura
to Picnic Point Road.
From the Tocumwal
turnoff, Picnic Point Road continues unsealed to Picnic Point alongside
the Murray River. There are camp grounds and a lodge here. There is
a boat ramp at Picnic Point. The small riverside riverside alongside
the Picnic Point Caravan Park is a good bird watching spot as such birds
as White-browed Scrub Wrens, Red-browed Finches, Superb (Blue) Fairy
Wrens and Nankeen Night Herons are used to campers and rather timid.
There are public toilets alongside the narrow riverside reserve.
At Picnic
Point, a bridge over Gulpa Creek gives access, after passing by several
private dwellings and Tarragon Lodge, to Moira State Forest. It is possible
to drive alongside the Murray atop a natural silt jetty for many kilometres.
After several kilometres, a locked gate limits further vehicular access.
It is worth walking alongside the river from here to Moira Lake. But
a word of warning. It ay not be a good idea to try to walk around Moira
Lake as there a lot of snakes in high grass between the Moira Channel
and Moira Lake. So many, that it is hard to avoid treading on one with
possible nasty consequences! Most of the snakes are Red-bellied Blacks
and they are unlikely to be aggressive unless trodden on or approached
too closely.

Red-bellied
Black Snake (D Ong)
A
day on Gulpa Island
by (the late) Pat Corry
East
of the Cobb Highway between Deniliquin and Echuca, extending back along
the flood plain of the Murray River towards Tocumwal, are more than
35,000 hectares of State Forests. These River Red Gum forests contain
many unusual features of great interest and are criss-crossed by a number
of picturesque forest drives.
I would like
to take you on a drive through one of our favourite spots, Gulpa Island.
Gulpa Island
is bounded by the Edward River and the Gulpa Creek. The drive is about
15km. It commences at Mathoura and can be entered by crossing Polly's
Bridge at the Gateway Caravan Park on Gulpa Creek.
Turn sharp
left past the bridge and continue beside the creek, stopping at the
cattle grid.
You will see
on your left a scarred tree. The scar marks the place where an aborigine
has removed a sheet of bark to make a canoe many years ago.
A short distance
further on, look away to the left and you will see the Cadell Tilt.
There is a
north-south fault in the Earth's surface. The land to the west rose
up to 10m above the land to the east, some thousands of years ago. This
altered the course of the Murray River by blocking its flow (the old
course is the present-day Green Gully). A lake formed the the east of
the fault, the waters of the Murray building up (a greater Barmah Lake)
until water spilt out, some flowing South towards Echuca, some flowing
north (Edward River and various creeks) through Deniliquin. The two
arms rejoin some 200 kms west.
While observing
the flora and bird life, follow the Gulpa Creek Road. You will see a
lonely remnant of the original stand of Sandalwood. Continue on and
you will see Blue Rod, Slender Hopbush, Narrow Hopbush, Ruby Salt Bush
and Kurrajong.

Calytrix
tetragona
Melville Road
and Langman's Road will take you through to sand ridges with large numbers
of native trees, shrubs and other plants such as Murray Pine, Cooba,
Grey Mulga, Cherry Ballart, Calytrix (Fringe Myrtle), etc which are
all common on the sandhill. Some areas are fenced for preservation and
walking around these you can see the following native regrowth: Banksia
marginata, Pale-fruit Ballart, Buloke, Clematis microphylla,
Common Fireweed, Nodding Saltbush, Blushing Bindweed, Woollyhead Mat
Rush, Austral Bugles, Cranberry Heath, Flannel Cudweed, Common Wheat
Grass, Shrubby Riceflower and Native Jasmine. Kangaroos and emus may
be sighted on your journey.
On a day there
we saw more than 50 species of birds, including Superb Parrots and a
large number of Friarbird. From where we sat having lunch, we watched
nesting pairs of Diamond Firetails, Striated Pardalotes and Rainbow
Bee-eaters busily feeding their young.

Superb
Parrot (D Ong)
You may pass
many camping and fishing spots along the way and will re-enter the Cobb
Highway some 12km north of Mathoura.
As you leave
the forest, observe the large regrowth of River Red Gum that struck
after the 1993 floods. You will also notice the high flood levels on
the trees. We hope you enjoy this tour as much as we do.
Pat
Corry had many interests. Amongst other things, Pat was amongst the
first to campaign for the protection of roadsides which were rich in
native grasses and significant indigenous vegetation. The above notes
were written about 10 years ago. Webmeister.
Gulpa
Forest Walks ~ pdf brochure
(Shire of Murray and Mathoura Chamber of Commerce)
Gulpa,
Millewa and Moira Forest Drives ~ pdf maps
(Forestry NSW)
Moira
Forest and Moira Lake Flora Reserve
Moira
Forest is located south of Picnic Point Road. Motorists travelling along
the Cobb Highway on the Cadell Tilt Block can see over the tops of the
trees in Moira Forest to the east.
There is a
delightful forest drive through Moira Forest. Enter the forest from
a well-sign posted turnoff along the Cobb Highway about half way between
the Shepparton-Barmah Road and Mathoura. Drive along Poverty Point Road
to Poverty Point picnic ground and then follow Narrows Road alongside
the Murray to Porters Creek Road. Follow Porters Creek Road to Coolaman
Road and return to the highway. Narrows Road can also be accessed via
a bridge over Gulpa Creek at Picnic Point. At the end of the drive,
it may be worth stopping at the western side of Moira Flora Reserve,
an area of Box trees.
Several years ago,
work began on restoring Moira Lake to its original condition ~ it used
to be a great fishing spot in the early days of European settlement.
The Murray River and Moira Channel act as barriers to the movement of
cattle. Fencing has been erected on the other sides of the Moira Lake
flora Reserve. Cattle have also been excluded from the reserve, resulting
in the return of many plants which have been uncommon for many years.
Regulators have been constructed along Moira Creek so that water can
be allowed to enter the wetland over Winter and Spring but prevented
from entering over Summer and Autumn, allowing the wetlands to dry out
as they once did prior to river regulation. Unfortunately, high river
flows for irrigation and water supplies in summer can sometimes exceed
the capacity of the Murray, here known as the Bar bah choke, so that
summer flooding sometimes occurs. The final stage of the restoration
involves the relocation of the Moira Channel and/or a By-pass around
the Choke.
Left:
Moira Lake ~ sometimes allowed to dry out in late summer and autumn.
(K Stockwell)
If you can visit here, the raucous
cry of flocks of Sulphur-crested cockatoos coming form the red gums
will remain etched in your memory for years to come.
When Moira Lake contains water, a
large number of terns and water birds may be observed.
Stage 3, the final stage, of the
Moira Lake Restoration Scheme is planned. The final stage involves the
relocation of the Moira Channel downstream and rehabilitation works
along the site of the present channel. The lake is presently dry but,
because Giant Rush has taken over, it no longer resembles the way it
was when the photograph was taken a few years ago. A thick blanket of
rush grew to over one and an half metres tall in just six months.
Millewa
Forest
That part
of the forest east of The Edward (River) and north of the Murray River
is termed Millewa Forest. Millewa Forest Road (also called Tocumwal
Road and formerly called Aratula Road) runs through this section of
forest. Some tracks lead south from Millewa Forest Road to the Murray.
There are some good camping sites along the river in this section. A
few decades back there were some holiday shacks alongside the Murray.
This have now all been demolished. Some of the trees planted around
the shacks remain. Upstream of Picnic Point there is such a spot with
many fruit and garden trees, Walthours Garden. When the forest is not
in flood, seldom-used tracks in the vicinity of Walthours Garden are
suitable for bush walking. Further upstream the Murray becomes a braided
stream with many lagoons. Yet further upstream is a large meander with
a narrow neck and it is here that anglers sometimes choose to camp.
Gulpa,
Millewa and Moira Forest Drives ~ pdf maps
(Forestry NSW)
Bama
Forest
This State
forest is located in NSW alongside the Murray River downstream of Barmah
Town. It is generally regarded as part of the greater Barmah-Millewa
Forest. Much of this forest consists of Box which has been logged in
the past. Therefore, many of the trees have multiple stems from a stump.
Adjoining private property is used for "paint ball". Some
adjoining farmers have allowed bushland to regenerate on part of their
properties.
Formerly
part of the ancient Lake Kanyapella, Bama State Forest is a flood retarding
basin, protecting Echuca-Moama from serious flooding. It is important
that flood waters can continue to enter this forest. Map
reference: Mathoura 1:50,000 (Central Mapping Authority of NSW)
Bullatale
(Tuppal) Flora Reserve
Located
alongside The Edward (River) south of Deniliquin and north of Gulpa
Island, this large flora reserve is part of the Barmah-Millewa Forest.
Ulupna
Island
This red gum
forest is located in Victoria upstream of the Barmah-Millewa Forest,
north of Strathmerton. Morgans Beach is a popular beach located between
Ulupna Island State Forest and Barmah Forest. Reference: Strathmerton
7926-S 1:50,000 (Central Mapping Authority of New South Wales). VEAC
recommends that his area be part of Barmah National Park.
Other
NSW reserves in the forest
Other reserves on the NSW side of
the Murray include Bullatale (Tuppal, north of Gulpa Island), Toupna
Creek (NW of Hills Road) and Sanddune Pine (south of Fire Hut Rd). In
addition, there are a number
of 'exclosures'. Grazing, forestry and other extractive activities are
not permitted in these reserved areas.
Other
Victorian reserves
Opposite Bama Forest and downstream
of Barmah is Echuca Regional Park and some
state forest, much of which lie between the Murray River and Echuca-Nathalia
(Stewarts Bridge) Road. There is also forest and wetlands alongside
the Goulburn River which enters the Murray downstream of Stewarts Bridge.
Much of these forests form parts of the proposed Lower Goulburn River
National Park. A short distance from the Goulburn River is Kanyapella
Basin. These areas are listed separately.
Bushwalking
A walking track has been constructed
alongside Gulpa Creek at Mathoura. The walk can be started at either
Cranes Bridge (on the northern edge of Mathoura near the mandarin orchard)
or near Polly's Bridge, Mathoura to Picnic Point Road. There are several
foot bridges over Gulpa Creek and the section of track nearest Polly's
bridge is a loop. The final bridge, linking sections 1 and 2 of the
walkway, was opened during 2006.
A good spot for walking is probably
on Gulpa Island. A day-long circuit can be done incorporating Tea Tree
Road (the plants are actually fringe myrtles or Calytrix tetragona),
Langmans Road and Gulpa Creek Road. Tea Tree Road follows a sand ridge
(lunette) which has been fenced in places to protect the feeding grounds
of rare birds as well as to encourage the regeneration of banksias,
hop bushes, Calytrix and other plants. Those behind this idea are to
be applauded as the fences keep rabbits and cattle off the environmentally-sensitive
lunettes. A degraded sandhill in the Millewa Forest has also been fenced
to exclude cattle and revegetation work will be undertaken.
Another good walk on Gulpa Island
is from Cranes Bridge via Sages Track to the Edward River Bridge, Tocumwal
(Millewa Forest) Road. A good topographic map is needed and it is a
good idea to do a 'recce' beforehand. The birding along Sages Track
is usually outstanding: Emu, Southern Whiteface and Diamond Firetail
are usually seen.
Several off-track walks are possible
but flooded runners and wetlands may prove a hindrance at times.
There is an easy half-day circuit
walking track from the picnic ground at Barmah Lake along Broken Creek,
across to the Dharnya (Information) Centre (presently closed) and back
through the forest to Barmah Lake.
Moira
Grass plains
Over
the years, Europeans have exploited the forest. The forest is still
logged and has been grazed by cattle, although these activities are
being excluded from the exclosures and flora reserves on the NSW side
of the Murray. Logging is no longer permitted in Barmah State Park.
Cattlemen
were attracted by Moira Grass, which is green in summer when surrounding
lands are barren. The removal of cattle in Autumn is termed "The
Barmah Muster" and has become somewhat of a tourist attraction.
(Cattle were removed from the forest in 2007 and not permitted to
return until the grasses recover from the present drought. April 2008.
Webmeister).
Moira Grass
plains are becoming increasingly uncommon in the forest. In the past,
deep flooding killed young saplings and favoured the growth of the grass.
With irrigation and river regulation, large floods are uncommon so fewer
Red Gum saplings are now drowned by flooding. Red Gum forest and Giant
Rush have replaced much of the Moira Grass plains. Giant Rush (Juncus
ingens) is capable of growing in height by 11mm per day. Cattle
find Giant Rush unpalatable.

Red Gum
(K Stockwell)
Cattle
On the
NSW side of Barmah-Millewa forest, cattle licences permit cattle
to be grazed for a period (e.g. six months) in certain areas. The forest
is then rested for a period.
The forest on the NSW side of the
Murray is divided into sections. Over winter, cattle may be allowed
in areas where introduced grasses can be targeted. Cattle grazing may
be allowed on higher sections of the forest, where they are unlikely
to damage boggy wetlands, during summer. There are also exclosures in
which cattle are not normally permitted. Some of these areas are wetlands.
As flood waters recede, cattle can cause cause soil and vegetation damage
(pugging) in wetlands. Sometimes, some cattle may be used in these for
a short period to help control weeds. Forest administrators follow the
guidelines set out in a document titled Riverina Grazing Strategy, copies
of which can be obtained through Forestry NSW (a division of the NSW
Department of Primary Industries).
Some of the exclosures are areas
which have been fenced to protect certain plants (e.g. Banksia)
or animals (e.g. Gilbert Whistler). As is the case with cattle, logging
and vehicles are not normally permitted in exclosures.
The VEAC draft
proposals report proposes that cattle grazing not be permitted in Victoria
in the proposed Barmah Forest National Park.
In Victoria, cattle are removed
from the forest in autumn. 'The Barmah Muster' is held in autumn and
attracts many tourists. The VEAC draft recommendations set aside some
land near the Dharnya Centre so the Muster to continue.
According to research evidence, to
help control weeds and to promote the growth of indigenous grasses,
grazing is best done between easter and late July provided, however,
the soil is dry. Cattle should not be resent over spring and summer
when indigenous grasses are flowering and setting seed. If and when
it is appropriate to graze an area, sheep, being lighter, may be more
appropriate insofar as they cause less damage. At Terrick Terrick National
Park, sheep are used as an ecological control to reduce weeds and to
maintain suitable conditions for the endangered Plains-wanderer. There
is a case for ecological grazing being used in Barmah-Millewa Forest.
Some argue
that the cattle reduce the "fuel" on the forest floor and
lessen the danger of fires. Others argue that cattle grazing may increase
the fire risk by spreading weeds and by promoting the spread of woody
weeds and less palatable plants such as rushes. Cattle prefer to eat
the most palatable plants and these may therefore become less common.
For example, reeds are more common along streams where grazing has not
occurred often e.g. the town side of Gulpa Creek at Mathoura.
A nasty fire
in the Top End in December 2006 occurred in an area where cattle had
grazed the less flammable indigenous grasses but promoted the spread
of highly inflammable rushes. According to fire fighters, the intensity
of the fire in the rush beds was virtually beyond belief, even in beds
that were flooded to help control the fire. Someone should have told
the cattle to eat the inflammable rush and leave the less flammable
grasses! So bang goes that argument. Cattle can actually increase the
fire risk!

A
cow grazes in forest of the Top End after the 2006 fire (K Stockwell)
Prolonged
drought conditions may have contributed to the severity of recent fires,
the causes of which appear suspicious. An unattended camp fire may have
been to blame or the campers may have deliberately ignited the fire.
Camp fires (using solid fuel such as wood) are banned in the NSW side
of the forest over summer and the VEAC draft report recommends they
also be banned on the Victorian side of the Murray River.
There are
other ways of reducing the fire risk, e.g. cold burns in winter.
Owing to severe
drought conditions, cattle were removed from the forest by mid 2007
and, at the time of writing, had not been permitted back.
At Kinnairds
Wetland, weeds are cut before they flower and are baled for hay. Perhaps,
in places, this could be done in Barmah-Millewa forest.
There is no
doubt that cattle grazing reduces plant diversity. When cattle are removed
from an area, plants which have not been common may become more common.
At Terrick Terrick, some old trees and shrubs not common in the park
grow near the cemetery. Since cattle grazing ceased, many young specimens
of these plants have appeared and are growing well. There are no specimens
of intermediate age: in all probability, the cattle ate them.
Cattle cause
major damage on sand ridges where they not only prevent the regeneration
of banksias, hop bushes and wattles but may destroy the nesting tunnels
of Rainbow Bee-eaters.
They also
cause problems in reed bed swamps, pugging the soil and reducing the
vegetation cover.
If cattle are allowed to graze when
the soil is wet, pugging occurs.

Pug
marks at the edge of Hut Lake (K Stockwell)
Some (e.g. local botanist Howie Marshall)
argues that 'pugging' (marks made in mud by cattle hooves) helps provide
suitable habitat for certain indigenous plants. Others argue that pugging
compacts the soil and damages the environment.

Cracking
soil is good but are the pug marks bad? (K Stockwell)
Although many
argue that pugging is bad, most ecologists agree that soil cracking
is essential. Drying wetland beds consolidate and aerate sediments,
alter the phys-chemical properties, and may serve to strengthen macrophyte
communities upon re-wetting. If a wetland is to be a good food source
for wildlife when it next floods, a drying and cracking stage is desirable.
Giant Rush
is an indigenous species that is, unfortunately, taking over too much
of the rich biodiversity of the Moira Grass Plains. Unfortunately, cattle
avoid eating it.
In places,
cattle damage the river banks and eat out reeds which, when present,
help prevent bank erosion. There is a growing realisation that cattle
should be excluded from such areas and, in places, fencing has been
erected to protect sensitive areas, e.g. on sandy areas along Picnic
Point Road, along Millewa (Aratula) Road, along Tea Tree Road and along
Langmans Road in Gulpa Island. Recently, the Reed Beds and Moira Lake
have been fenced off. The number of cattle which can be grazed under
lease has been reduced significantly over recent years and more power
given to land managers.

Cattle
alongside the Murray River in Barmah State Park (K Stockwell)
Cattle grazing
is bad news for birds such as robins which feed low in the forest. These
birds need cover and perches. But the cattle tend to eat the lower branches
of saplings and break off many of the twigs which would otherwise serve
as perches.
Some argue
that a cost-benefit analysis should be undertaken, comparing the benefits
from grazing (income from license fees, weed control, etc) with the
costs (increase in non-palatable grasses, reduction in incidence of
palatable species, reduction in the diversity of vegetation, pugging,
administrative costs, damage to river banks, spread of weeds, etc).
On balance,
cattle probably do more harm than good. Excluding them from the forest
is probably a good thing environmentally. Nonetheless, there may be
times and areas where grazing is desirable, e.g. to maintain optimal
conditions for Bush Stone Curlews or to help control weeds. To promote
native grasses and help control weeds, it may be best if cattle grazing
is limited to certain areas and to dry periods in winter. The VEAC report
recognizes that there is a case for environmental grazing.
Timber
harvesting
Forestry
directly and indirectly employs hundreds of people, especially in the
Barmah-Koondrook area. Value-adding is becoming increasingly important
and magnificent furniture is being made from red gum. An expensive laminating
plant has been installed at Barham. Red Gum veneer can be used for flooring
and wall panels as well as for table tops and in furniture construction.
Fine quality red gum furniture is sold in Koondrook and in Echuca.
Although it
is claimed that logging is becoming increasingly conservative, the extent
of logging seems to have been cranked up a few notches over recent years.
Old trees unsuitable for forestry are no longer being ring barked: in
face, habitat trees are retained in forestry coups. Foresters claim
that only a small percentage of the forest is logged each year (there
is a 20-year cycle) and only a fraction of the trees (as low as 20%)
in each coupe are logged.
Some claim
that over-logging is still occurring and some spots of high ornithological
significance have been logged recently, e.g. an area alongside the Langmans
Sandhill Exclosure on Gulpa Island, a spot where Gilberts Whistler,
Superb Parrot, Diamond Firetail, White-browed Babbler and Brown Treecreeper
have been often recorded.
Red Gum is
susceptible to fire, relying on flooding for regeneration.
Most of the
timber extracted from the forest is used for firewood or garden chips.
Much of the firewood and chips are produced from forest residues, from
thinning operations and from trees damaged by fire. Some are critical
of the amount of firewood taken from the forest. Most of the firewood
goes to Melbourne and provincial cities. Some argue that, because smoke
contaminates the atmosphere and adds to greenhouse gases, wood fires
should no longer be permitted. Smoke from wood fires causes some distress
in the neighbourhood, especially to those with respiratory problems.
Gas fires cause less greenhouse pollution and are unlikely to diminish
the air quality of neighbours.
In order to
collect or cut wood from the forest, a permit is necessary. Two chaps
were recently fined around $3,600 for cutting firewood without a permit.
The law is enforced, rangers and police patrolling the forest and manning
entrance points at times.
In view of
the low annual average rainfall of this area, Red Gum requires periodic
flooding. Much of the forest has not received sufficient water over
recent years. In parts of the forest, the trees are stressed and therefore
subject to insect attack, placing their future value as timber trees
at risk. It is in the interest of foresters that areas of red gum forest
receive 'floodwaters' from time to time.
VEAC's draft
report recommends that forestry be excluded from the proposed Barmah
National Park but notes that there is a case for environmental thinning.
Such timber could be available for sale as firewood to help defray the
cost of the thinning. VEAC has recommended that, because of the importance
of the timber industry to Barham-Koondrook, forestry be allowed in forest
areas near Barham-Koondrrook.
Indigenous
occupants
Several
Koori tribes, including the Bangerang, inhabited the area for thousands
of years. Collectively, local tribes form Yorta Yorta nations. Many
indigenous persons reside in the area.
Yorta Yorta found an abundance of
food in the area. Until recently, they operated the Dharnya Centre,
a cultural and educational centre, along the Sandridge Road near the
turnoff to Barmah Lake. The centre has been closed owing to termite
damage. Hopefully the centre will be revamped and reopened sometime
fairly soon.
Some cultural
or sacred sites have been fenced off, e.g. areas with middens (piles
of shells marking camping sites).
One fenced
site of significance is Garradha Molwa (Bucks Sandhill). This sandhill
is badly degraded and in need of revegetation to restore its cover of
indigenous trees, shrubs, herbs, lillies and grasses.
Some trees
bear evidence that a bark bowl (coolamon), bark shield or bark canoe
has been cut from them. Such trees are referred to as Coolamon Trees.
One is sign-posted near the southern end of Gulpa Creek Road. A road
in Moira Forest which runs roughly parallel to the Cobb Highway is called
Coolamon Road.
Attempts are
being made to involve indigenous persons in the administration of the
forest. At this stage, various aboriginal groups have been approached
to help determine whether or not they wish to be involved in the process.
Progress is being made and the VEAC Report recommends indigenous co-management
of the proposed Barmah National Park.
Management
To co-ordinate water
and help manage the forest, a cross-border body, the Barmah-Millewa
Forum was established. This forum included representatives from government
and non-government bodies from both sides of the river, e.g. Parks Victoria,
Forestry Commission of NSW, Murray-Goulburn Water, Shire of Murray,
Bird Observers Club, Barmah Protection League, Forest Users Group, irrigators.
Some criticised the Forum, saying that cattle, irrigation and forestry
interests are over-represented. But the Forum served a worthwhile purpose
and helped managed the forest as a whole, with representatives of groups
from both sides of the State border. The Forum was financed by the Murray-Darling
Commission. In recent years, the Forum studied flooding patterns and
installed regulators and levee banks so that pre-1799 flooding patterns
could be simulated.
Under the Living Murray Initiative,
the Ministerial Council designated the Barmah-Millewa Forest as one
of six icon sites in the Murray-Darling Basin which was in need of protection.
The Murray itself is another of the six 'sites'. Associated with the
Living Murray initiative, the Forum has been replaced by a new structure
(see below).
Management
of Barmah-Millewa Forest
The forest straddles the border of NSW and Victoria. Under The
Living Murray Agreement, a cross-border liaison body, the Barmah-Millewa
Forum was scrapped. A new structure was set up.
Early in
2007, the Australian government asked the States for permission to 'take
over' the Murray-Darling Basin. NSW, Queensland and South Australia
signed off on the proposal but Victoria did not do so until March 2008.
The agreement may impact on the structure which is outlined below.
There
is Barmah site manager and a Millewa site manager. These managers take
turns at acting as a Chief Site Manager. A Project Officer was employed
to assist the site managers. Unfortunately the project officer position
has been vacant since the end of 2007.
They are assisted
by a Co-ordinating Committee, a Technical Advisory Committee and the
Barmah-Millewa Consultative Reference Group. Indigenous representation
is being organised.
Co-ordinating
Committee. The Co-ordinating Committee's main function is to assist
the asset manager to develop and implement cross-border consultation
process and to develop an asset environmental management plan (AEMP).
Other functions are:
to co-ordinate the Project Officer
to
assist with reporting requirements
Members of
the CC:
Lead
Asset Manager (alternating between Forestry NSW and DSE Victoria)
(Chair)
Alternative
Asset Manager
Murray
CMA representative
Goulburn Broken CMA representative
Victorian Department of Primary Industry (DPI) representative
Victorian Department of Environment and Sustainability (DSE)
representative
Commonwealth
Department of Environment and Heritage (DEH) representative
Parks
Victoria representative
NSW Department of Infrastructure, Planning and Natural Resources
representative
MDBC/River
Murray Water representative
two
members of the Barmah-Millewa Asset Consultation Reference Group
plus the Project Officer
The Co-ordinating
Committee would be likely to meet at least twice per year, in March
to review the asset environment management plan (AEMP), and in October,
which coincides with environmental water allocation releases.
Technical
Advisory Committee. The Technical Advisory Committee meets as required
and provides technical advice, preparing annual environment management
plans (AEMP) and annual reports and would oversee implementation of
the AEMP (water application, environmental works). The Technical Advisory
Group comprises representatives of Forestry NSW, DSE, Parks Victoria,
Murray CMA, Goulburn Broken CMA, DNR, Goulburn Murray Water and experts,
e.g. scientist from the Arthur Rylah Institute.
Asset Consultation
Reference Group. The Asset Consultation Reference group is to provide
community input into developing and implementing the Asset Environmental
Management Plan. Membership is by application and is limited to about
18 persons.
Indigenous
Engagement. Indigenous persons are to be included in water planning
and management as per current respective jurisdictional protocols. In
NSW, since 1983, there have been local and regional Land Councils and
these will have a role. In Victoria, it is expected that Indigenous
engagement would involve the recent Yorta Yorta Joint Management Agreement.
Kevin Ritchie, the Victorian Barmah-Millewa Asset Manager, sits on the
Yorta Yorta Joint Management Body and provides an added link with the
Victorian Government agreement with the Yorta Yorta nations. A person
has been appointed by the CMAs to liaise with indigenous persons. It
is expected that there will be indigenous representation on each of
the six icon CRGs.
(By March
2008, the indigenous representative committee had still not, to the
best of my knowledge, been formed owing to difficulties deciding upon
the composition of the group, difficulties finding persons prepared
to sit on the committee, and the fact that the project officer position
has been vacant. Webmeister).
It is the
duty of the committees to prepare operating water plans. Community input
is allowed for. Meetings of interested persons are to be convened in
Nathalia, Mathoura and Echuca-Moama on 28th and 29th March 2007, just
prior to the Easter school holidays. The sessions will feature an interesting
Powerpoint presentation on the history of the forest and the impact
of the environmental water release over 2005-06. See the Murray Shire
newsletter (The Enterprise) and the Riverine Herald for
details.
Source: the
above was based on Barmah-Millewa Forum meeting address by Mike Thompson
2004. The outline has been amended to accord with subsequent developments.
E. & O.E.
Some argue that the entire Barmah-Millewa
Forest ~ not just the Victorian section ~ should be a national park.
Whatever the outcome, the entire Barmah-Millewa forest should be managed
even better than it has in the past. First and foremost, more water
is needed to flood parts of the forest over Spring. The good thing about
the NSW exclosures and Moira Flora Reserve is that they are reasonably
well-managed by local employees of the Forestry NSW, both long-serving
staff and younger locals, who between them have a wealth of experience
and local knowledge which must not be lost if and when the forest is
given national park status. The present 'exclosures' on the NSW side
of the Murray are effectively national parks insofar as forestry, fishing,
vehicles and grazing are excluded and insofar as restoration work is
well under way and nearing completion.
Prolonged drought has, however, had an adverse impact upon the vegetation
and wildlife.
Map references: Mathoura 1:50,000
and Strathmerton 1:50,000 (Central mapping Authority of New South Wales).
Forestry Commission (Victoria) maps are apparently no longer available.
A new map of the forest, covering both sides of the Murray, was prepared
by the Barmah-Millewa Forum which was dissolved in 2005 but, unfortunately,
the map does not appear to be on sale to the public.
Should
Barmah-Millewa be a national park?
Barmah-Millewa
Forest Icon Site Environmental Management Plan (available on CD from
MDBC GPO Box 409 CANBERRA 2601; phone 02 6279 0100)
VEAC Discussion Paper Victoria's Red Gum Forests (VEAC
Nicholson St. Carlton Victoria)
Here are some more notes about
the forest.
News
Barmah-Millewa
Wetlands dry out
As most
of the storages along the Murray and its tributaries contain little
water, it is unlikely that environmental water will be released in the
foreseeable future. It is hoped, however, that environmental water can
be released into a few small wetlands so that they can act as drought
refuges for native fish and waterbirds.
Reports suggest
that there will be no further releases of water from Jindabyne and,
if substantial rains do not fall soon, that the Murray could cease flowing
later this year. If it was not for storages, the Murray would, by now,
be reduced to a chain of waterholes.
The Murray
is still flowing strongly downstream of Yarrawonga at the moment (January
2007), with much of the water destined for Adelaide. But wetlands have
either been drained or allowed to dry out.
Almost all
of the wetland areas in the Barmah-Millewa Forest are dry. The Reed
Beds near Picnic Point (southern Riverina) have been dry for several
months. Even 'permanent' wetlands such as Hut Lake in Barmah Forest,
have now dried out. Permanent wetlands provide a drought refuge for
both native fish and birds.
An interesting
email report ~ which was written by Keith Ward last month ~ has been
received, outlining the effects of drought on wetlands of the Barmah-Millewa
Forest.
Having mentioned
that a major drought refuge, Hut Lake, had all but dried out, Keith
Ward states:
"Fortunately
it is not all doom and gloom. The drying bed will consolidate and
aerate the sediments, alter the phys-chemical properties, and may
serve to strengthen macrophyte communities upon re-wetting. Giant
Rush, an indigenous species that is, unfortunately, taking over too
much of the rich biodiversity of the Moira Grass Plains, will not
find the conditions favourable. This is a good thing."
It sure is,
provided waterbirds can survive until these wetlands receive water.
Some appear to have moved to northern Australia or into town lagoons,
some are finding a refuge in sewage farms (i.e. waste water treatment
facilities) whilst many may have perished. According to a report on
the ABC news, a recent aerial waterbird survey recorded record low numbers.
In order
to provide a rich source of food for water birds, wetlands need to dry
out at times. So, when the wetlands next receive water, there should
be lots of food for waders and other waterbirds. But Keith Ward points
out a paradox:
"the drought
paradoxically often means that parts of the Barmah wetlands get wet.
No, this is not a typo - just a consequence of the Murray River being
run too high in the quest of river managers' attempt to deliver as
much water as possible through the Barmah Choke (a natural constriction
within the river channel). The Giant Rush stands in those wetlands
are in complete heaven, and their advancement this year will now be
about the last nail in the proverbial coffin for many Moira Grass
plains. This is definitely not a good thing."
Before irrigation,
the Murray usually flooded the Moira Grass plains in spring,drowning
and killing any young Red Gum saplings which had germinated since the
last flood. With river regulation, flooding is less frequent and the
floods are lower, so the area of Moira Grass plain has contracted, Red
Gum saplings taking over. Most of the Moira Grass plains have been lost.
Obviously, the loss of this habitat has had an effect on the makeup
of the local bird population. Some birds have suffered, e.g. Brolgas,
seed-eaters, whereas others have benefited, e.g. White-plumed Honeyeaters,
nectar feeders. Anyway, Keith Ward continues,
"But it
gets more interesting - What isn't wet or dry has been burnt. A large
fire that begun in mid-October, under suspicious circumstances, burnt
about 800 ha of Redgum-rushland wetland system (pictures not included
here). Approximately 300 ML of water was diverted from the Murray
River to successfully douse some difficult to reach hot spots, however
the fire continues to re-ignite elsewhere from subterranean sources
(i.e., is smouldering along roots until it re-surfaces in an adjoining
tree). So much for the 'grazing reduces blazing' adage being exposed
by those with a vested interest. Someone should have told the cattle
that they need to eat the unpalatable rush instead of facilitating
the spread of it. The flammability of the material, according to the
fire-fighters, was practically beyond belief!
"Despite
this, the fire has actually provided a unique opportunity to reduce
the Giant Rush biomass. If we were now only to get some deep and long
duration flooding, then the Moira Grass may have the opportunity to
re-dominate. But like any good thriller, we now have a new surprise
contender - Arrowhead. This introduced species is rapidly taking over
vast areas of wetlands and water supply systems throughout north-eastern
and north-central Victoria, including Barmah. It prefers shallowly
flooded open systems, and has so far failed to colonise Top Island
because of the Giant Rush. But with the rush now out of the way, and
Arrowhead choking every waterway leading into the wetland, conditions
are now set to enable this species to take over when the river next
rises."

Arrowhead:
a major threat (K Stockwell)
Comment:
Forest managers are particularly alarmed at the rapid spread of Arrowhead
and are finding it difficult to obtain the necessary permission to use
chemical sprays. The EPA of NSW prefers hand weeding but this is not
practical. Unfortunately, Arrowhead is only one of several invasive
water weeds threatening the Murray system (see 'weeds').
Mr Ward's comments were forwarded through an intermediary.
Download a copy of Mr Ward's
views with pictures.
Subsequent to Mr Ward writing
his comments, the prime minister has announced that engineering works
are to be carried out to solve the problem of 'Barmah Choke'. Any engineering
works carried out to by-pass 'The Choke' need to be carefully thought
out so that they do not become a white elephant. It must be remembered
that the Murray River is capable of flowing backwards in this area and
that the very existence of the wetlands depends upon the capacity of
The Narrows ('The Barmah Choke') being exceeded in late winter and spring.
About 90% of the water which floods the wetlands will eventually drain
back into the Murray. As Mr Ward's article makes clear, a drying phase
is desirable over late summer and autumn. So if any by-pass is constructed,
ideally it would only be used over late summer and autumn, thereby allowing
the wetlands to dry out. The by-pass would need to be long so that the
water does not simply flow 'backwards' up the Murray and into the forest
over summer and autumn. K Stockwell, webmeister, January 2007.
Cattle
ordered out of Barmah-Millewa
Because
of the damage cattle are causing to dry wetlands during the present
prolonged drought, chief icon site manager for Barmah-Millewa Forest,
Kevin Ritchie, has asked graziers to remove all cattle from the Barmah-Millewa
Forest by the end of January. Kevin's decision has been backed by several
conservation groups, including the Victorian National Parks Association.
Cattle licensees are disappointed insofar as this year's Barmah Muster,
an event which usually attracts hundreds of visitors to the area, appears
likely to be brought forward. Cattle have already been withdrawn from
forests downstream of Barmah-Millewa, including Gunbower Island. There
are reports that some cattle graziers have protested against the decision.
At least one local MP has supported the protesters ~ did he first tour
the forest with the forest manager or a professional ecologist to study
the extent of the problem through their eyes? January 2007.
* Cattle
owners who removed their cattle from Barmah Forest earlier than usual
in 2007 were compensated. Cattle are still excluded from the forest
because of drought conditions. April 2008. Ed.

Supporters
of cattle grazing protesting against the site manager's decision. (N
Roberts)
Potential
threats to Barmah-Millewa Forest
Potential
threats include:
- inappropriate
water management (quality, frequency, season, duration)
- inappropriate
timber harvesting (e.g. reducing the number of old habitat trees,
allowing stumps to resprout as multiple-stemmed trees, over-logging,
failing to retain strong saplings which can become future timber and/or
habitat trees, destroying shrubs and ground layer)
- inappropriate
grazing management (erosion of banks, changed vegetation mix, weeds,
summer grazing, grazing damaging wet soils)
- fires (Red
Gum does not respond well to fire but depends upon flooding for regeneration)
- weeds (e.g.
Arrowhead, Basket Willow, thistles) and further encroachment on wetlands
by Giant Rush and Red Gum

Arrowhead:
a major threat (K Stockwell)
- feral animals
(e.g. rabbits, brumbies, pigs)
- environmental
vandalism
Damage
at the site of Murrays Mill caused by hoon drivers.
The area has been a feeding area for several robin species each winter
but robins abandoned the site on the day when this damage occurred
and were not been sighted there for the remainder of the 2007 winter.
(K Stockwell)
- barriers
to fish movement (e.g. weirs and regulators which lack fish ladders
prevent fish movement along waterways)
- barriers
to water movement